Motion Picture Visual Comparison
Motion Picture Visual Comparsion
November 24th, 2022
Taking a deeper look into the visuals cinema can use to create specific emotions and responses. In this example I use Citizen Kane, The boy in the Striped Pajamas, and The Champion. No need to have seen these movies.
Analysis
So I found a common theme in many of Citizen Kane's imagery is a great divide and a sense of this impassable fence between two worlds. This is shown with mirrors, water reflections, and my choice of visual: fences. This idea that you can catch a glimpse of the other side but to be allowed to wander freely in that world is an unattainable dream is a common occurrence in war films as well. I am particularly familiar with WW2 as both of my grandfathers fought in this war and survived to tell about it.
Image #1 from Citizen Kane
In Image #1 from Citizen Kane, you can see a gorgeous, large, and rich castle behind a strong, wrought iron fence. It is so close that even in the dark of night you can see the details of windows and count the towers. The fence, however, stretches across the entire screen, and despite its large, decorative holes, it is clear there is no entrance possible.
Image #1 from Movie of Choice (The Boy in the Striped Pajamas)
I compare this picture with Image #1 from my Movie of Choice, The Boy in the Striped Pajamas. In this image from The Boy in the Striped Pajamas, Shmuel is close enough to Bruno that he can converse with him and play checkers. However, even though he could clearly climb through the holes of the barbed wire fence, he doesn't dare even touch the checker pieces for fear of getting shot.
Image #2 from Citizen Kane
My analysis of Image #2 from Citizen Kane is a little simpler. In Image #2 we see a fence and nothing else. Fog covers any image we might have been able to see and all you can see is a barrier or impossible obstacle. The lattice pattern holes and thin wire almost seem to taunt us into wanting to overcome the obstacle, but because of the thick fog, unknown dangers could be waiting on the other side. In this image, fear is what is causing us not the overcome the fence.
Image #2 from Movie of Choice (The Champion)
Comparing this image to Image #2 from my Movie of Choice, The Champion, Fear is the key factor hindering escape in this image as well. The large gaps between the barbed wire taunt us into wanting to escape with nothing but a few gashes, but the armed nazi guard reminds us that the fence is the least of our worries. If we do escape, what then? Past the fence is open, fruitless land, with no shelter for hiding during an inevitable pursuit.
In conclusion, all four of these images drive fear into our hearts and foster a feeling of perpetuating separation from the unknown "other" world, a need to escape our situation, defeat before we have even begun, and a morbid curiosity for what lies on the other side of the fence. The fence symbolizes the feeling of exclusion and the contrast between the two sides of the fence symbolizes the feelings of inadequacy.